Simple and Consistent Parenting: Ten Key Strategies


Photo courtesy of Christa Meola.

This is a guest post written by Barrie Davenport of Live Bold and Bloom.

If you have children under the age of 18, you may not remember the old television program, Leave It to Beaver. It was a family sitcom in the days when the mother (June) wore a dress with pearls and heals to do the dusting, and the master bedroom featured perfectly-made twin beds. Hmm.

The star of the show, Beaver, is a pre-pubescent boy who gets into all kinds of shenanigans like keeping an alligator in his bathtub and teasing his friend Lumpy (what’s with that name?).

Watching the re-runs now as an adult, I have noticed a brilliant parenting strategy on the part of June. Whenever Beaver pulls one of his stunts, her initial reaction is always the same — “Beaver, just wait until your father gets home.” Now there’s some consistent parenting. Delegate the hard stuff to dear old dad.

As a parent, you can probably sympathize with June’s strategy. When children start doing what they do, it would be so much easier to let someone else deal with it, especially the other parent involved. In the heat of the moment, when your beautiful precious one is tearing out his sister’s hair or screaming her lungs out at the grocery store because you have refused her the package of jumbo beef jerky, it’s hard to know exactly what to do.

Most of the time you just want to escape the situation because it’s just so unpleasant.

Scottie, beam me up, pleeeease! Even if you could just evaporate, it’s probably not legal, and eventually you will have to deal with the behavior that is most certainly bound to repeat itself.

After raising three children who are now teenagers (the youngest is 13), I have learned a few things the hard way. Before kids, I swore I’d never feed them chicken nuggets, own a minivan or live in the suburbs! I’ve since eaten my words and more than my share of leftover nuggets.

The most important thing I learned is that parenting is relatively simple if you focus on this one thing: consistency.

Being consistent is harder than is sounds, but the effort it takes is well-worth the long-term results. When children know, without a shadow of a doubt, that you say what you mean and mean what you say, their behavior rapidly falls in line. Without the yelling, arguing and tantrums. If you do your job.

It’s nearly impossible to be consistent when you are in a reactive mode. When you are angry or frustrated in the moment, it’s natural to yell, “You are grounded for life!” But later you might have to take that back. Not good.

The key to consistent parenting is preemptive planning.

As parents, you must determine the expectations and rules for your family that are comfortable for you and age-appropriate for your children. You know your children and the particular naughtiness du jour they use to torment you. If you dwell on your little darlings, you could easily list the expected behaviors that are likely to appear on any given day.

So instead of waiting for your husband or wife or whomever to come to your rescue, take action! Create a plan that let’s your children know exactly what to expect, while you remain a Zen parent — calm and in control.

Here are some strategies for creating a consistent parenting plan:

1. Set a meeting. If you are married, set a meeting with your spouse. If you are single, ask a trusted friend or family member to brainstorm with you. Look at the existing discipline issues you have with your children. What are your expectations for appropriate behavior around those issues? Write them down. Brainstorm other rules or behavior changes you would like to implement.

2. Determine consequences. Ultimately, you want your child to have internal control over his or her behavior. Appropriate consequences begin as an unpleasant reminder to children and later become a measuring stick for ethical actions, as you train your child’s conscience. Review your list of family rules and behavior changes, and think about consequences you would implement for infractions. As you consider the consequences, keep the following in mind:

  • Are they age appropriate?
  • Are they natural or logical based on the misbehavior?
  • Are you able to consistently follow through with them?
  • Will your child learn from the consequence?

3. Include your children. Once the adults in the family have met to outline rules and consequences, include your children in the discussion. Older children can have a voice in the discussion around family rules and consequences. Invite their input and ideas, and remain open to making realistic adjustments at their request. The more your children are engaged in the process, the less resistant they will be to accept and comply to the rules.

4. Clearly communicate the plan. After you have created a final plan for rules and consequences, write up a “contract” with your children. The written word has power and can serve as a visible reminder that there are rules and everyone knows them. Verbally review the rules and consequences with your children in a family meeting, and even ask them to sign the contract. Post it where everyone in the family can see it.

5. Expect the test. Now that you have a signed contract, do you expect your children will immediately transform into perfect angels? They are kids, and it’s their mission in life to test you. “Mom and Dad have created these goofy rules. That was a fun game, but now let the wild rumpus begin!” You know they are going to test you, so expect it. Now you have a perfect opportunity to put your plan into action.

6. No yelling necessary. When the bad behavior begins or the rule is broken, your initial reaction will be your fallback position — anger. Don’t fall into that trap. Remain Zen. Calmly walk your child to the fridge door or wherever you’ve posted the rules, and peacefully state, “I see you have broken our agreement about rule #4. The consequence we agreed to is . . . .” This may happen a few times before they really understand you mean business.

7. Don’t waffle or give in. Whatever you do — don’t break the pattern of consistency. Once your child knows that they can weasel their way around a rule or out of a punishment, they have your number. It will take you twice as long to regain the ground you lost with inconsistent consequences.

8. What if you’re wrong? Sometimes you might be unsure about a behavior problem or broken rule. When siblings argue, they always point the finger at the other. If you aren’t in the room, it’s hard to know the reality of the situation. Follow your instinct and knowledge of your children. But even if you are wrong, it won’t kill them to be punished occasionally when it’s not their fault. There will be plenty of times they get away with mischief you never know about!

9. Be flexible and make adjustments. There may be extenuating circumstances or situations in which you let something go. Explain that to your child, and let them know why you are making an exception. As time goes by, you may need to alter the rules or adjust the consequences. When children get older, naturally you will need to make adjustments. But you might find that some rules need tweaking or some consequences aren’t working. When you make any changes, be sure to implement the same family meeting process you did initially.

10. Don’t forget the praise. If you are consistently consistent, you will see your child’s behavior improve. Children like the security of knowing what to expect and having safe and predictable boundaries. With every step they make in the right direction, offer them love and praise for their accomplishments. The will soak it in and use that positive energy to continue to make you proud.

As the poet Kahlil Gibran reminds, “You are the bows from which your children as living arrows are sent forth.” If you are a stable and consistent bow, your arrows will fly straight and far.

Barrie Davenport is a personal and career coach and founder of Live Bold and Bloom, a blog about bold and fearless living. Download her free ebook, How to Have a Meaningful Life.

1 trackback

Top 10 Links of the Week | Live [Simply] Free
June 26, 2010 at 6:54 pm

19 brilliant commentsadd a comment

Mark June 21, 2010 at 10:06 am

“Kids Are Worth It!” by Barbara Coloroso. Highly evolved approach to parenting and very consistent with the parenting philosophy often conveyed by this website.

Eric - BHF June 21, 2010 at 10:52 am

Great Ideas. My son is 2 and consistency and discipline are becoming more important everyday. I just wish that is was as easy as you make it sound! Thanks for the post.

Melissa Gorzelanczyk June 21, 2010 at 11:10 am

Hi Barrie – Nice to see you here! These are great tips and I think one of the best things about have a parenting plan is – it helps your own sanity! There’s nothing more frustrating than a child that won’t follow the rules and not knowing what to do. Having a plan makes a more confident parent. We all need a dose of that to guide our children.

Great post.
Melissa Gorzelanczyk

Joseph Nally June 21, 2010 at 12:33 pm

Like the emphasis on honing our consistency. Key to successful parenting. In fact, I think we rob our children of a full childhood when we’re inconsistent.

There is a lot in this post to chew on. Perhaps taking it bit by bit until more completely assimilated.

Barrie Davenport June 21, 2010 at 3:17 pm

Mark, thanks for the recommendation. I will have to check out that book. I hope it’s not too late for me with teenagers!

Eric, yes it is rarely as easy as it sounds! But keep trying. If you are consistent most of the time, eventually your children will respond. And if not, you have the comfort of knowing you did the right thing for them!

Hi Melissa! Great to see you here too. A plan is the only way to go. Without one we might run away from home!

Hi Joseph — I like your comment – we rob our children of a full childhood when we’re inconsistent. You are so right. Kids need to be kids and have the security of knowing what to expect from us. Thank you for commenting.

Barrie

Alison Kerr @Fun Books for Kids June 21, 2010 at 6:00 pm

‘…it’s natural to yell, “You are grounded for life!” But later you might have to take that back. Not good.’
I had to chuckle at that one Barrie. Kids can really bring out the badly behaved, out of control, kid in all of us. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve seen a parent who is obviously embarrassed by their child’s behavior making a great big fool of themselves in public by making even more fuss than the kid. As a parent it’s wise not only to be consistent, but to learn to recognize and respect the limits of both ourselves and our children.

Barrie Davenport June 21, 2010 at 8:56 pm

That is so true Alison! I have been reduced to infantile behavior by my teenagers! They sure know how to push the buttons. That’s why a cool detachment often comes in handy. Thanks for jumping over and checking out Sherri and Leo’s blog. It’s a great resource.

Jean Sarauer June 21, 2010 at 9:29 pm

Don’t you just love all those things we swear we’ll never do or say when we have kids of our own? That could be a post in and of itself!

I liked that you included that kids will test us. It really does help if we expect that this challenging of the boundaries is going to happen and prepare for it. That would go a long way towards reducing the number of parental meltdowns :)

Vince Robisch June 21, 2010 at 9:44 pm

Great post! #5 is absolutely true. I think moving #10 up to #1 has helped a lot in my house.

Barrie Davenport June 21, 2010 at 10:00 pm

Jean, that’s a great idea. A post on all the times we had to eat our words when raising kids. I might choke on the post!

Vince, you are right, number 10 should be first. Sometimes we are so busy training and socializing our kids that we neglect to say the obvious — how wonderful we think they are. (Except when they are stinkers!) Thanks for commenting.

Manal June 22, 2010 at 12:40 am

Great advice Barrie.
I am going to print this and send it to a few of my family members so they can stop yelling and do something else :)

John Sherry June 22, 2010 at 2:52 am

Kids above all else need love, support, security and encouragement but the glue that holds that together is gentle discipline underpinning it. Tough love doesn’t do it for me but love with simple do’s and dont’s imparts knowledge and understanding both of which you portray nicely in your post Barrie. We can feel you care about doing the right thing and helping your child evolve in an atmosphere of nurture. Bless you for opening eyes and debate to a sometimes thorny issue.

Barrie Davenport June 22, 2010 at 10:05 am

Manal, I hope your family members embrace a gentler approach. Yelling is the last resort before your head blows off. It’s better to just plan ahead so you don’t get to that point!

John, thank you for your thoughtful comments. I have not always practiced what I preach, but I sure try. I never feel good about losing my temper. To raise calm and respectful children, you have to model that behavior!

Françoise June 22, 2010 at 5:17 pm

Hi Barrie,
all your points are valuable and need to be put into action. From my point of view the one stating to clearly communicate the plan seems to be very important. It happens so often, that we thought about something, decided it and wonder why nobody understood what’s happening … simple truth: we forgot to share it with the others … strange how often it happens that we think others can read our thoughts …

Barrie Davenport June 22, 2010 at 6:55 pm

Hi Francoise,
Yes, communication is especially important with children. They have selective hearing anyway, so sometimes you have to communicate things many times before they get it. And before they believe you mean it. Thank you for your thoughtful comment!

Devi June 23, 2010 at 7:27 am

My kids are 12 and 6 and they so wonderful when they are not screaming at each other. Ive not been able to implement the rules but the no yelling seems to work on them real well. Talking to them really helps too.

Barrie Davenport June 24, 2010 at 7:52 am

Hi Devi,
I agree — the screaming certainly makes them less appealing! I think talking to them without yelling is brilliant. A calm parent is so much more effective than an angry one. Thank you for commenting.
Barrie

Jess@minimalistmum June 27, 2010 at 5:02 am

Also highly recommend “How to Talk so kids will listen and listen so Kids Will Talk…” by Adele Faber and Elaine Mazlish. So much more than just common sense…

Maria June 29, 2010 at 5:29 pm

“Unconditional Parenting” is a good book (or DVD if you don’t have time to read). “Radical Unschooling” is also a great parenting book (despite it’s title) – very Zen.

I don’t think the punishments & rewards/behavioral approach is really effective in the long term, unless you wish for your child a life of forever seeking to achieve rewards (extrinsic motivation vs intrinsic motivation). I think new, emerging style of parenting is one of connection with the child’s needs and desires, true acceptance of the child as a child (and as that specific child), and re-evaluating what is really going on inside ourselves that causes us to have expectations of our children and how we hurt our children by having them. There is no need to set consequences, because there are natural consequences to every choice a person makes. By creating consequences, we are disregarding this natural law, and instead of helping our children to see the consequences of their choices, we are helping them to figure out ways to get around the consequences. I.e. I stop at the red light not because I don’t want to get a ticket, but because I don’t want to hurt myself and others. This helps build empathy, which is already very strong in children, but is often squashed when the adults around him/her don’t return that empathy. To suggest that “waffling” is somehow bad, is built on the grounds of authoritarian (bully) parenting, same with the idea of consistency. I’d prefer to be consistent in my flexibility, that I can and do change my mind and that this is okay, it’s human nature, everyone does this on a regular basis. Do I really want my child to model a kind of consistent stubbornness and unwillingness to change? Not really.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: